Client Reviews — Slavey & Shumaker PLLC
Real testimonials from real clients. See why Morgantown trusts our attorneys for personal injury, civil litigation, and criminal defense.
Why Client Reviews Matter When Choosing a Morgantown Attorney
When you or someone you love is facing a serious personal injury, car wreck injury, criminal charge, or find yourself involved in civil litigation, choosing the right attorney can change everything. Before you call our office, we invite you to read what clients have experienced working with the attorneys and staff of Slavey & Shumaker PLLC.
Every review displayed here was posted directly to our Google Business Profile by a real client who retained our firm. We have never solicited, incentivized, or edited any review. Our 4.8‑star rating across more than 101 reviews reflects the commitment Tyler Slavey, Brandon Shumaker, Scott Harris, and Kasey Libby bring to every matter we handle throughout Morgantown, Monongalia County, and North Central West Virginia.
Whether you are searching for a personal injury lawyer in Morgantown, WV after a car or truck accident, or need an experienced criminal defense attorney for a DUI, drug charge, or serious felony, these testimonials provide honest insight into what to expect from our firm.
Featured Client Testimonials
Highlighted reviews from clients across all practice areas
“I had the privilege of working with Brandon Shumaker and couldn’t be more thankful for his representation. While my case initially seemed open and shut, the process leading up to trial became unexpectedly complex. Brandon handled every development with a calm, clear-headed approach and a thorough understanding of the law. His communication throughout the entire proceeding was diligent, timely, and always appropriate—keeping me informed and confident at every step. He also showed genuine kindness and patience during what was a stressful time for me. I truly appreciate his professionalism and dedication. I highly recommend Brandon Shumaker to anyone in need of reliable and compassionate legal representation.”
“I don’t have the words to fully express our gratitude to Brandon for the support he gave our daughter during an incredibly difficult time. His professionalism, compassion, and unwavering commitment to securing the best possible outcome for her legal situation brought tremendous relief to our entire family. Brandon’s fees were extremely fair for the level of service he provided. In fact, he even refunded us for unearned time—something we never expected but deeply appreciated. We give him our highest recommendation.”
“I can’t recommend this law firm highly enough! Their legal services are top-notch, delivering results with precision and expertise every step of the way. The attorneys showed incredible courtroom savvy, navigating complex proceedings confidently and effectively to secure the best possible outcome for me. What stood out most was their outstanding communication—clear, timely updates kept me informed. The entire team was also incredibly friendly and approachable.”
Personal Injury and Civil Litigation Client Reviews
Car accidents, truck accidents, and civil injury claims throughout Morgantown and Monongalia County, WV
“Brandon was the best to work with! After my car accident, he made the settlement process extremely easy, stress-free, and he was quick during the process too. He helped me out a lot and got me exactly what I needed, would definitely work with him again if it is necessary!”
“I can’t say enough positive things about my experience working with Tyler and this firm. From start to finish, they were professional, caring, and incredibly supportive. Tyler walked me through every step of the way handling a sensitive matter with compassion and integrity. Their communication was clear, their guidance was honest, and their results spoke for themselves.”
“I had an excellent experience working with Brandon Shumaker. From our first consultation, he was professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely cared about my case. Thanks to his expertise, my case had a very successful outcome. I highly recommend Slavey and Shumaker to anyone seeking legal representation.”
“Tyler Slavey helped my husband and I with a civil matter in our neighborhood. It speaks volumes how humble, caring, and down to Earth Tyler and his team are. Tyler went to bat for us like a champ! I would absolutely recommend him and his team to our families and friends. It’s all about trust, empathy and service—and Tyler embodies that!”
“Tyler was absolutely phenomenal. He helped me through the absolute hardest thing that I’ve faced in my entire life, and walked me through it step by step and made sure every single question that I had was answered. I HIGHLY recommend Slavey & Shumaker for all of your legal needs!!”
“These guys are the best. Their attention to detail is extraordinary. They investigate every option to ensure you get your maximum entitlement. I was expecting one amount and was pleasantly surprised to have gotten more. If you are looking for knowledge, honesty, and efficiency, call Slavey and Shumaker.”
Criminal Defense and Civil Litigation Defense Client Reviews
DUI, drug charges, felonies, expungements, all criminal, and Civil Litigation defense matters in Monongalia County courts
“I had the absolute best experience with Brandon. He made everything easy and quick with his time and experience. My case was dismissed due to Brandon’s hard work and knowledge. I highly recommend Brandon and his law firm for any needs you may have. 5 stars!”
“I highly recommend Brandon Shumaker and the Slavey & Shumaker team. Brandon was exceptionally responsive and thorough, ensuring we felt prepared and confident throughout the entire process. He is a diligent advocate who genuinely cares about his clients. I wouldn’t hesitate to work with them again.”
“Working with Brandon was an incredibly smooth process and helped me relieve the troubles throughout my case. I would highly recommend.”
“If you find yourself in need of legal counsel I highly suggest Slavey & Shumaker. They will work hard for you! Extremely knowledgeable and compassionate firm. The hands-on, boots-on-ground work Scott Harris put into my case was above and beyond.”
“Brandon Shumaker represented me in a criminal matter that ultimately was resolved in a dismissal. Communication was always on point, very professional and good at presenting and arguing your defense. If I ever find myself in a pinch again, I know who I’m calling.”
“Tyler helped me out with an extremely pressing and unique legal matter and I could not be more grateful. Everyone I interacted with at the firm were professional, courteous, and responsive. He went above and beyond for me and my family and I would highly recommend his services to anyone.”
Reviews by Attorney
Select an attorney to view reviews that specifically mention their work
J. Tyler Slavey
“I can’t say enough positive things about my experience working with Tyler and this firm. From start to finish, they were professional, caring, and incredibly supportive. Tyler walked me through every step of the way handling a sensitive matter with compassion and integrity, treating us with respect and keeping our trust throughout the entire process. Their communication was clear, their guidance was honest, and their results spoke for themselves. I’m deeply grateful for their help and would recommend them to anyone looking for a firm that genuinely cares about its clients and delivers exceptional results.”
“Tyler was absolutely phenomenal. He helped me through the absolute hardest thing that I’ve faced in my entire life, and walked me through it step by step and made sure every single question that I had was answered. I HIGHLY recommend Slavey & Shumaker for all of your legal needs!!”
“Tyler Slavey helped my husband and I with a civil matter in our neighborhood. It speaks volumes how humble, caring, and down to Earth Tyler and his team are. Tyler went to bat for us like a champ! I would absolutely recommend him and his team to our families and friends. It’s all about trust, empathy and service—and Tyler embodies that!”
“I called Tyler Slavey when I had issues with conservatorship for my grandmother as well as several complicated issues with her land and deed. He was able to give me advice as to what I needed to do next. He is honest and trustworthy. I would seek his services again.”
“Tyler was great. Communication was always on point, very professional and good at presenting and arguing your defense. If I ever find myself in a pinch again, I know who I’m calling.”
“Tyler helped me out with an extremely pressing and unique legal matter and I could not be more grateful. Everyone I interacted with at the firm were professional, courteous, and responsive. He went above and beyond for me and my family and I would highly recommend his services to anyone.”
J. Brandon Shumaker
“I had the privilege of working with Brandon Shumaker and couldn’t be more thankful for his representation. While my case initially seemed open and shut, the process leading up to trial became unexpectedly complex. Brandon handled every development with a calm, clear-headed approach and a thorough understanding of the law. His communication throughout the entire proceeding was diligent, timely, and always appropriate—keeping me informed and confident at every step.”
“I don’t have the words to fully express our gratitude to Brandon for the support he gave our daughter during an incredibly difficult time. His professionalism, compassion, and unwavering commitment to securing the best possible outcome brought tremendous relief to our entire family. Brandon’s fees were extremely fair. In fact, he even refunded us for unearned time—something we never expected but deeply appreciated.”
“Brandon was the best to work with! After my car accident, he made the settlement process extremely easy, stress-free, and quick. He helped me out a lot and got me exactly what I needed, would definitely work with him again if it is necessary!”
“I had the absolute best experience with Brandon. He made everything easy and quick. My case was dismissed due to Brandon’s hard work and knowledge. I highly recommend Brandon and his law firm for any needs you may have. 5 stars!”
“I highly recommend Brandon Shumaker and the Slavey & Shumaker team. Brandon was exceptionally responsive and thorough, ensuring we felt prepared and confident throughout the entire process. He is a diligent advocate who genuinely cares about his clients. I wouldn’t hesitate to work with them again.”
“I had an excellent experience working with Brandon Shumaker. From our first consultation, he was professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely cared about my case. Thanks to his expertise, my case had a very successful outcome. I highly recommend Slavey and Shumaker to anyone seeking legal representation.”
“Working with Brandon was an incredibly smooth process and helped me relieve the troubles throughout my case. I would highly recommend.”
“Brandon Shumaker is not only a great attorney, he’s a nice, down to earth person. Everyone at the firm was attentive if Brandon was unavailable. The whole staff comes highly recommended!”
Scott B. Harris
“Scott Harris, Esq. at Slavey and Shumaker provided excellent guidance and support. He was professional, responsive, and gave me peace of mind throughout the process. I’m very grateful for his help and would highly recommend him.”
“If you find yourself in need of legal counsel I highly suggest Slavey & Shumaker. They will work hard for you! Extremely knowledgeable and compassionate firm. The hands-on, boots-on-ground work Scott Harris put into my case was above and beyond.”
“I needed assistance navigating an unusual legal situation and I retained Scott Harris to do so. He was professional, quick, and incredibly helpful in helping me understand and manage the presenting issue. If I need a lawyer again Scott is definitely my first pick and I have recommended him to friends.”
Kasey Libby
“Kasey was absolutely brilliant. Very professional, knowledgeable, and reassuring. Hopefully I will not require these services again. If I do, I’m calling here first.”
Kasey Libby is a growing member of the Slavey & Shumaker team. As more clients work with Kasey, this section will be updated with their testimonials. If you have worked with Kasey, please share your experience on Google →
Are you a former or current client of Slavey & Shumaker PLLC?
Leave a Google Review →Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Slavey & Shumaker PLLC and our client reviews
How do I verify that Slavey & Shumaker’s client reviews are authentic?
All reviews on this page originate from our Google Business Profile. You can verify any review by visiting Google directly. The firm has earned a 4.8-star rating across more than 101 verified Google reviews. You can also view attorney profiles on AVVO.com or visit our Facebook Page.
What do clients say about J. Tyler Slavey?
Clients of Tyler Slavey consistently describe him as humble, caring, and down to earth. Reviewers highlight his step-by-step guidance through difficult legal matters, his honesty and trustworthiness in conservatorship and estate matters, and his willingness to go above and beyond in civil litigation and personal injury cases. Tyler is recognized as a Super Lawyers Rising Star.
What do clients say about J. Brandon Shumaker?
Brandon Shumaker receives consistent praise for his calm, clear-headed approach in complex cases, his compassion during difficult circumstances, and his diligent communication. Criminal defense clients frequently report case dismissals, and personal injury clients note stress-free settlement processes. Brandon has also received recognition for refunding clients for unearned time. He is recognized as a Super Lawyers Rising Star.
What do clients say about Scott B. Harris?
Scott B. Harris is praised for his hands-on approach, professionalism, and responsiveness. Clients describe him as knowledgeable and compassionate, noting that his work goes above and beyond expectations. Scott has received strong recommendations for both criminal defense and complex or unusual legal situations.
What do clients say about Kasey Libby?
Kasey Libby has been described by clients as absolutely brilliant, professional, knowledgeable, and reassuring. As a newer member of the Slavey & Shumaker team, Kasey’s Google reviews are growing. Clients who have worked with Kasey are encouraged to share their experience on the firm’s Google Business Profile.
Does Slavey & Shumaker PLLC offer free consultations?
Yes. The firm offers free initial consultations for personal injury and criminal defense matters throughout West Virginia. Call (304) 212-5791, email admin@sslawwv.com, or use the contact form on our website.
Who are the attorneys at Slavey & Shumaker PLLC?
The firm’s attorneys are J. Tyler Slavey (Managing Attorney), J. Brandon Shumaker (Managing Attorney), Scott B. Harris (Associate Attorney), and Kasey Libby (Associate Attorney). Both Tyler Slavey and Brandon Shumaker have been recognized on the Super Lawyers Rising Stars lists. The firm was founded in 2019.
Ready to Speak With a Morgantown Attorney?
Free consultations are available for personal injury, civil litigation, and criminal defense matters throughout West Virginia. No fee to discuss your case.
Request a Free Consultation Or call: (304) 212-5791Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The information on this website does not constitute legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.